Identity in Barbie World is not difficult to determine, because everything seems to be based on appearance in the virtual world. There are no activities to allow someone to show off their athletic skills, intelligence level or anything else that makes up a person. Who you are in virtual Barbie comes solely from how your doll looks. And how your doll looks comes from how much money the owner has.
When I walked around and noticed all of the Barbies, it was shocking and weird how awkwardly similar they all are. Does this generation of girls (or creepy men, or UC students) really all share the same taste in clothes, hairstyles, shoes and accessories? Probably not. Either everyone is conforming to the social ideology that all girls should wear pink dresses, which means people are having a serious identity crisis, or they do not have the money to hold “VIP” status in virtual Barbie and do not have the chance to go to the actual mall. The first time I went to the mall I became very angry because I was allowed to try on clothes, pick out accessories and get my hair done. Once I had finally perfected my Barbie look, I went to leave the mall. But I was told I could only wear these fantastic, stylish articles of clothing if I was VIP. So I pouted and left. Yes, I know, very immature, but this is my point- Barbie is enticing, mesmerizing and leads girls in the direction they want them to go, then tells them they can only be pretty, popular and hang out with the cool people if they pay the money to hold a higher status level. It reminded me very much of society.
After I continued to walk around in my boring clothes, the same ones that many girls had on, I quickly noticed who was in the free clothes and who was in the expensive, prettier clothes. I couldn’t help but be embarrassed that I didn’t have that. I thought to myself “this isn’t me.. I am being identified as a lower class citizen because I cannot afford the fun stuff.” The original, free clothes had an instant connotation of poverty. I think it is safe to assume that many other young girls feel the same way as they wonder around this virtual world. They get discouraged and at such a young age realize their level in society. As a kid, aren’t you supposed to be worry free and have fun? These girls enter a world to be careless and enjoy themselves, and instead they unknowingly are tempted with the beauties of society, such as dangling a carrot in front of a horse, and learn very quickly, and too early, that they are either above others because of their wealth, or are below normal class citizens because they cannot pay the $5 for an internet game.
After noticing whether the dolls were high or low class citizens, I began looking at the actual articles of clothing they girls had picked out for Barbie. One girl had on a mini skirt, crop top and boots. I thought “Is she trying to identify herself as a hooker?” Then I saw a conservative looking Barbie, complete with jeans, a t-shirt and gym shoes. I instantly thought “Ew, you couldn’t pick something out better than THAT?” Knowing your identity and being able to determine others is such a catch-22. The girl with the hooker look could have just really liked those 3 articles of clothing and put them on without thinking what her doll would look like. The girl with the jeans could be putting the same clothes on her doll as she does herself each morning. Who says that girls ages 6-15 must have fashion sense and be able to determine what people will think of them based on their outfit each day? But this is what society does- it continuously puts people in categories according to identity. The minute you walk out the door, people automatically see you as your race, your clothing style, the car you drive, and how you present yourself. Without looking any deeper, people can judge who you are before they have time to blink. Do you think that categorizing people according to identity, as society usually does, creates a greater division amongst the population or instead allows certain groups of people to actually come together?
I think that categorizing people according to identity allows certain groups of people to come together, and to develop their own identity better. Knowing that someone likes certain music that I like, makes me able to identify with that person because we share some aspects of a common identity. If one of my friends likes something different from me, causing us to not have a similar interest or identification with that item, I don't believe it separates us and causes a great division. Going back to my example with music and how that can be an item helping to create one's identity, maybe we like different artist, but maybe we are also showing each other new music. If I really like the music they show me, it can become a part of my identity or it could just be a difference between us, which I could use to learn about what shapes their identity.
ReplyDeleteIn addition to that perspective, a division among the population is created only if people allow it. An example of this can be seen through racism. African Americans and Caucasian Americans both share different identities of race. Being Caucasian I can choose to be open minded and have friends of all races, broadening my identity, or I can just shut myself off and create a division. If I do that latter option, I am only hurting myself I could be missing out on friendships or eye opening experiences of learning from someone with a different identity.